I’m thrilled to have finally found the perfect homemade gluten-free caramel sauce recipe to share with you! This homemade caramel sauce is thick, creamy, buttery and perfectly sweet. It stays soft at room temperature, and can be warmed just a bit for drizzling. It’s perfect for enjoying over gluten-free brownies and ice cream!
I’m not a fan of any store bought caramel sauces that I’ve tried – they’re very runny and just don’t have great flavor. They’re nothing like the thick and buttery caramel sauce that I grew up enjoying at Leatherby’s Family Creamery in Sacramento. While this isn’t an exact copycat of the Leatherbys caramel sauce, I like it even better!
I could not stop digging into this salted caramel sauce with my spoon! I ended up sending one jar over to my friend’s house because I knew I was going to eat the whole jar if I didn’t!
I’ve also got to tell you that this salted caramel sauce is very, very good drizzled over fresh popped popcorn! I may have eaten three bowls of popcorn drizzled with this caramel sauce last night – just to make sure I could recommend that to you!
Please note that you will be using a candy thermometer for this recipe. You’ll want to calibrate it to make sure it’s accurate. Here’s a great tutorial on calibrating a thermometer.
This caramel sauce is made with evaporated milk. You won’t use a whole can though – don’t make the mistake of reading 1 cup as 1 can. You will have some leftover.
One of my favorite ways to enjoy this homemade caramel sauce is over chocolate ice cream, and sprinkled with chopped almonds and a few mini chocolate chips. Sooooo good!
Love cheesecake? Drizzle this caramel topping over my gluten-free cheesecake for a decadent dessert! It would also be amazing on this chocolate mug cake. I’m ready to dig in!
Need a dairy-free caramel sauce? Make this vegan caramel sauce.
And now here’s the recipe for this amazing homemade caramel sauce!
Gluten-free Caramel Sauce Recipe:
Gluten-free Caramel Sauce
Thick, buttery gluten-free caramel sauce that is delicious over ice cream, popcorn, brownies or cheesecake. You can drizzle this caramel topping on pretty much anything!
Ingredients
- 2 cups sugar
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 3/4 cup Karo light corn syrup
- 1 cup evaporated milk (note: this is not a full can)
- 1 pint (2 cups) heavy whipping cream
- 1 cup (2 sticks or 16 Tbsp.) unsalted butter
- 1 tsp. sea salt
- 1 tsp. pure vanilla extract
Instructions
- In a large pot (tall enough for your candy thermometer to clip on to), combine the sugar, brown sugar, light corn syrup, evaporated milk, heavy cream, unsalted butter and sea salt. (So everything except the vanilla extract!)
- Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly with a rubber spatula. Be sure you are constantly scraping the sides, edges, and bottom of the pan and do not leave unattended for more than a couple of seconds.
- Continue cooking and stirring, monitoring the temperature with a candy thermometer until temperature reaches 224°. This took about 24 minutes for me, but will vary depending on your stove, pot size, and altitude.
- Immediately remove from heat and set hot pot on a cooling rack or trivet.
- Stir in pure vanilla extract.
- Let cool before serving. Store leftovers in jar at room temperature or refrigerator. You can microwave the sauce for 20-30 seconds to warm and thin the sauce for drizzling again.
Notes
I do not recommend trying to cut back the sugar, nor do I recommend substituting with dairy-free alternatives This is definitely a buttery, sugary treat.
Recommended Products
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Party time!! Just as I did last year, I’ve gathered some of my favorite gluten-free bloggers to host a virtual ice cream social for these hot summer nights! Each blogger is sharing a recipe for a gluten-free ice cream, topping, popsicle or other cool dessert.
Check out the other 11 gluten-free recipes from my fellow blogger friends. Any of these would be perfect for your ice cream party or just for dessert on any hot night!
Creamy Earl Grey Infused Ice Cream by Fearless Dining
Gluten Free Vegan Brownie Ice Cream Sandwiches by Sarah Bakes Gluten Free
Gluten Free Mud Pie by What the Fork Food Blog
Chocolate Caramel Sundae Sauce by The Heritage Cook
Chocolate Sandwich Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches by Celiac and the Beast
Dairy Free Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pie by Allergy Free Alaska
Vegan Unicorn Pudding Pops by Flippin’ Delicious
I hope you enjoy this gf caramel topping too! Please come back and rate and review it once you’ve tried it!
Carolyn
Wednesday 17th of August 2022
I am curious as to how long this lasts in the fridge AND on the counter at room temperature? Thanks.
Gluten-free Cheesecake Recipe
Sunday 23rd of January 2022
[…] you ever had cheesecake topped with caramel and nuts? Make my gluten-free caramel sauce or purchase gluten-free caramel sauce at the store, and top with chopped almonds or pecans. If you […]
alyssa | everydaymaven
Friday 28th of June 2019
Making this for my kids - they will freak! And, thanks for including my mug cake!
Leah
Thursday 24th of August 2017
I am happy to have found your blog through this giveaway. I am looking forward to exploring your recipes with my daughter (who has celiac disease). Thank you!
Carrie Jacobsen
Thursday 24th of August 2017
Theze ice cream recipes you've compiled look amazing. I'm intrigued by the Earl Grey one...